Friday, August 03, 2007

congressional blowup over illegal immigration vote...

from 'the politico' blog....

By The Politico's Patrick O'Connor
Note: This item originally appeared on The Crypt, Politico's behind-the-scenes blog about Congress.

In a massive flare-up of partisan tensions, Republicans walked out on a House vote late Thursday night to protest what they believed to be Democratic maneuvers to reverse an unfavorable outcome for them.

The flap represents a complete breakdown in parliamentary procedure and an unprecedented low for the sometimes bitterly divided chamber.

The rancor erupted shortly before 11 p.m. as Rep. Michael R. McNulty, D-N.Y., gaveled close the vote on a standard procedural measure with the outcome still in doubt.

Details remain fuzzy, but numerous Republicans argued afterward that they had secured a 215-213 win on their motion to bar undocumented immigrants from receiving any federal funds apportioned in the agricultural spending bill for employment or rental assistance. Democrats, however, argued the measure was deadlocked at 214-214 and failed, members and aides on both sides of the aisle said afterward.

One GOP aide saw McNulty gavel the vote to a close after receiving a signal from his leaders – but before reading the official tally. And votes continued to shift even after he closed the roll call - a strange development in itself.

Whatever the final tally, acrimony quickly exploded between lawmakers on either side of the aisle as Democratic leaders tried to plot a solution, while parliamentarians on either side argued over protocol.

Majority Leader Steny H. Hoyer, D-Md., eventually offered a motion to reconsider, according to floor staff on either side, ostensibly giving members a chance to recast their votes. But the maneuver sparked a chorus of angry protests from the Republicans, yelling “shame” on Democrats, while they returned fire with angry volleys of their own.

When Democrats finally moved to consider the spending bill as the last vote of the night, furious Republicans left the chamber en masse to protest the maneuver. The House eventually recessed at 11:18 p.m. But Republicans quickly discovered that there was no longer any record of the controversial vote and immediately charged Democrats with erasing the bad result.

“Obviously, the Democrats don’t want to stand up against illegal immigration – so much so that they’re willing to cheat in order to win a vote,” Rep. Patrick McHenry, R-N.C., said in an e-mail. “They’re desperate – and it shows.”

The official House website did not show a record of the vote as of 1 a.m. Friday.

36 comments:

Anonymous said...

Neither party really wants to change the current immigration laws (or lack of) because the group that controls Congress (Big Business) does not want any changes. As long as profits are up, due to lower labor costs, no EFFECTIVE changes will ever be put into law.

Homeland security & Medicare cost overruns will always take a back seat to corporate profits.

Anonymous said...

The Republicans stood with the American people, with legal and deciding votes, NOT give government aid in the form of welfare, food stamps, wic, etc.. to illegal aliens. The democrats pulled a fast one to send the bill back to committee. They didn't like the outcome and could care less how the American people felt about the issue.

Anonymous said...

Illegal aliens qualify for free meals at the school....thats BS!

Anonymous said...

I am not even shocked by the Dem. congressmen's actions. These people have created a voting block of idiots wanting handouts and always have the media down the throats of anyone who slips up the slightest bit if they do not stand with them. The sad thing here is that this will not be investigated and will be swept under the rug. Any TV media attention this receives will be short and not very explanatory so that most viewers won't understand and figure since they aren't beating it to death like they do any Rep. situation then it must not be important. If a Rep. majority in this day and age had done this on an extremely hot topic such as this all hell would break loose and every dumb-ass liberal hippie college kid would be camping out in DC.
Another example why you should not vote for these clowns.
Rev.MJB

Anonymous said...

For anon 6:00 PM
You are somewhat right about the want for change and that shows with both major parties at times, but the people with a voice in Washington DC that oppose this idea of handing out money to ILLEGAL Immigrants are, for the most part, all Republicans. They should have enough sense to be one strong voice against this issue but then again the people should have enough sense not to elect LIBERALS.
Rev.MJB

Anonymous said...

What I don't understand is why we don't build the freakin wall! We've got a serious security issue at the southern border.

Our federal government has a contractional obligation with us (the people) according to the US Constituion to provide the common defense. Bush is seriously SERIOUSLY failing on that front (pun intended).

Bush and Congress, build that dadgum WALL! After that, then play politics with the folks who are here illegaly.

Did i make myself clear? BUILD THE WALL!!!!!!!!!!!

wdm said...

It's politics. The legal resident hispanics are now the largest minority in America. The democrats know they have the black vote (about 95%) and the white vote will split about 50/50. So they know that getting the hispanic vote this upcoming election is their ace in the hole. As much as I can't stand the democrats, they are using the illegal immigration issue to sink the Republican party to a tee. They used this exact same issue to gain control of the house and senate last election (does anyone remember?) and this time it will be to get the White House. The best term to describe today's Republican party is "divided we fall."

wdm said...

It's politics. The legal resident hispanics are now the largest minority in America. The democrats know they have the black vote (about 95%) and the white vote will split about 50/50. So they know that getting the hispanic vote this upcoming election is their ace in the hole. As much as I can't stand the democrats, they are using the illegal immigration issue to sink the Republican party to a tee. They used this exact same issue to gain control of the house and senate last election (does anyone remember?) and this time it will be to get the White House. The best term to describe today's Republican party is "divided we fall."

Anonymous said...

What about Medicaid this gov't assistant program robs form the medicare. Medicare is for when you get retirement age. Medicaid is for the low life people who don't work and take care of their own.

Anonymous said...

how you gonna build a wall...mr bush done said that construction is the kinda job americans wont do....have to have mexicans to do that kind of work....and food service...and yard work....and sewing jobs....and roofing..and painting.....and tree triming....and road way cleanup....and hotel cleaning....mr bush thinks the only jobs americans will take is high paying jobs with benefits.....yet he continues to try to talk businesses into stopping benefits and letting us pay for our own benefits.....soon we will have no jobs that americans will take....so sad...only in american.....whats up with that

Anonymous said...

Blame both Dems & Republicans! I don't recall the Republicans even attempting introduce any bills to change the immigration laws while they were in control of Congress.

Anonymous said...

I hope you can't vote 1:04 PM. That's one of the problems in the USA today. People are allowed to vote and thay have no idea what or who they are even voting for.

When stupity elects the leaders we end up with ignorance rules.

1:04, this has to do with a walk-out and why.

You are obviously a liberal defending liberals with no idea why you are doing it or what they are doing. Are you saying that the American taxpayer should pay to support illegal aliens? Are you also saying they should be allowed to vote? (WDM Comments)

It's a scary world we live in and people like you make it scarier.

Anonymous said...

104-
Changing ILLEGAL immigration laws to better the lives of ILLEGAL aliens is not exactly a good idea. The US is full of pu$$ies like you that think we are all equal, guess what, we are created equal but then your free will takes over and changes a lot of people like you into pansies and losers. We don't need to take in all losers from all countries.
Rev.MJB

Anonymous said...

Take a look at what type of people vote Democrap.
The bottom of the barrel and college kids with no idea of how the world REALLY works.
Blacks vote Democrapic religiously and we all know just how safe and productive America is thanks to their ideas.
Thank-you Black America for letting us know just how bad it could be in the USA if we all followed your lead.
VOTE HILLARY OBAMA 2008- if you want the white male to be insulted even more!
Rev.MJB

Anonymous said...

I get tired of being told I am an immigrant, because my ancestors came here in the 1700's. I feel I have been here long enough to say this is our Nation, and we can pick and choose who come here. Jumping the border was not the way my ancestors got here. They were shipped here to get them out of UK.
Why dont we do the same. Ship out those who we want to get rid of.

Anonymous said...

I sure wish my ancestors had some immigration laws. The white man better do something or else all he will end up like me & only have some casinos to call home.

Anonymous said...

12:01 You asked how we going to build a wall when Americans don't do that kind of work.

I did that kind of work during summer breaks while in College. There were plenty of Americans doing that work too. (and some Mexicans of course.)

Listen if we stop all this FREAKIN socialism guberment hand out crap, then we could wake some people up off of the welfare roles and get them to build the wall.

If we still need some illegal labor to do it, then when we finish the wall, we ask the illegals to check the other side to make sure that its ok. When they're on the other side, we shut the door.

Anonymous said...

We can solve the illegal immigration problem with 2 bills. One bill to build the WALL! The 2nd bill is what I would call the Foreign Exchange program. This program works like this:

1) The illegal must prove himself to be a very good worker.

2) He must have never ever ever used any of our communist social programs.

3) For every illegal that meets those previous two conditions we have to toss out some lazy welfare joker. I mean toss em over into Mexico, revoking his citizenship and don't let em back in.

Anonymous said...

if you are gonna let them work here, live here, send their kids to school here, pay taxes here, get driver licenses here, use government services here, and etc......then you gotta let them vote here.....end of story..

Anonymous said...

on all these blog pages i read comments from redneck republicans griping about all the problems in american today....but then they say how great mr bush is and the good job he is doing.....he has had 7 years, why hasnt he fixed anything.....7 yrs into the clinton administration, you didnt here the democrats complaining aboout the country.......maybe the republicans are just a bunch of complainers period.....maybe they will never be happy.....STOP THOMPSON NOW

Anonymous said...

Hey anon 6:29 pm,

You'd complain too if someone came and took your hard earned property in the name of socialism.

If you were to get off of your butt and start working, then you might start complaining too.

If however, you do work for a living, take a chance and look at your pay stub to see all the goofy stuff that your money is going too.

Americans on social programs, I challenge you to start carrying your "fair share". That's right, don't make this a generational thing. Change your family tree now!

Anonymous said...

Your right, we choose not to settle for government handouts and socialist ideas being passed around by Democraps. You my friend are an idiot and I'll bet you have offspring that are just as dumb as you. Go to Cuba were people give a damn about your ideas on how the world should give itself to you.
What did Clinton do there big guy.
What are any top tier Democraps going to do besides raise taxes and put us irreversibly headed towards socialism.
Do you know what Socialism is?
Do you care?
Do you disagree with the death penalty?
Do you agree with Abortion no matter why it is being done?
Do you like N!gg@ Day?
Do you see a problem with the word n!gg@ but not with Redneck?
Do you think the Barnesville NAACP is anything besides a bunch of prejudice minds gathered to share prejudice information?
Do you think that Affirmative Action IS NOT a slap in the face to the pursuit of happiness?
Do you think Government schools are doing a fine job?
Do you think the ACLU is really here to protect all rights for all individuals?
Do you really think the Islamic radicals are going to show your children mercy?
Do you really think people like me are going to show Liberals mercy when the crap hits the fan next go round?
We are the last remaining hope for this country to stay free, and we are not all Republicans but we sure as hell ain't Democraps!
AMERICAN MONEY COLLECTED FROM SWEAT AND LABOR FROM INDIVIDUALS MAKING THIER OWN WAY -PRESENTED TO- THOSE WHO REFUSE TO MAKE THIER OWN WAY THRUOGH SWEAT AND LABOR= The Democrapic Way Of Life AND The Socialist Plan For F#CKIN UP AMERICA!
Hit me with the facts there big guy!
Rev.MJB

Anonymous said...

Rev MJB,

You pretty much said it. I do however have a problem with the N word because it does offend a lot of good friends mine. The term Redneck really doesn't offend me. It's a stupid label that I've gladly turned around as a badge of honor.

Two things you forgot to mention.

1) Bush is really a frikin lib.
2) The money that we earn is actually twisted. What I mean is, it is loaned to our guberment by the Federal Reserve (a private bank - not public. Don't let the name "Federal" deceive you.) All of which makes no frikin sense because the Constitution gives the Congress the right to print money. Any way this hard earned-twisted money of ours is loosing value daily because of inflation. This would not be so if we were again tied to gold.

GILLRILLA said...

Sorry guys youre trying to re invent the wheele. The answer is easy we got code enforcement.Send them to every job site in town every day and pic up the illegals.if they can not get work here they will go away.

Anonymous said...

Bill Clinton was the worst example of a president I have ever seen. He supposedly smoked marijuana (but didn't inhale) he was a liar and a cheat and a skirt chaser. What kind of example is that for a child to look up to? HE IS THE MOST PANZY-ASSED PRIESIDENT THERE EVER WAS.

Anonymous said...

i bet if clinton and bush could both run for president again....and ran head to head.....clinton would win 4 to 1 against the light weight, do nothing legal, economy ruining, ex-drunk, wife beater.....

Anonymous said...

do you think we have less government give aways, less tax for ordinary people, less corruptions, less national debt, more national respect, and more money in our pockets now than we did when clinton was in office......yall a bunch of idiots if you think Bush has done alot of good for middle class.....He is a bigger spender than the clintons, he just spends it so it helps the very rich

Anonymous said...

1132 1135-Do you think that Universal Health Care is a huge step towards socialism? I would love to know.
Bush is not the greatest Prez. ever, but very few Presidents have had this many natural disasters, this much public pressure and defense issues as this Prez. has. You must understand that ALOT, but not all things, were either out of his control (Katrina, 911, Bridge Collapse) or inherated from past leaders who wanted a pass on that issue. We are still truckin as a nation, even though it could be alot better, but circumstances beyond this Prez.'s control have greatly limited what he planned to do for this country. He did not plan on being elected to fight a war or see hundreds of Americans be killed by Natural Disasters. Clinton could have dealt with terrorism but he chose to do as little as possible so that he could always say he had nothing to do with anything that happened unless it was a good thing.
Did you know that Clinton is the Prez. who put NAFTA in place and this was the serving Prez. when Osama declared Jihad against the USA? I will also be honest and say that it was a Rep. maj. in congress and I myself do not have a problem with NAFTA. American QUALITY should overcome any foriegn good or service IF we can just get all the tax burdens out of the way. If things keep going the way they are-HUGE trade deficeit, Social Security on the Brink, Dumbass Americans that can't say no to buying things they can't afford, The actual praise of more Socialized ANYTHING- our country will either be forced to tax the living hell out of us- NO NO- or cut Gov. benefits that are not being used as designed anyways and boost our businesses through the FAIRTAX PLAN.
I know there are alot of other scenarios and more info that's deeper than this but in a nuttshell, what used to be a future problem has now become the problem at hand PLUS the US WILL be forced to either surrender or defend itself from terrorism for the rest of this countries life!
We do not have the overflowing resources for this as we stand today, yesterday, or years before. The enemy caught us at a the perfect time!
Rev.

Anonymous said...

socialized medicine is now a dirty word in america....drug co. and ins co has killed that phrase along with national health care .....I am a firm believer in medicare.....medicare is a very cheap program...for the amount of care the person gets for the cost to the gov. and cost to the person.....cant imagine this country without medicare.....and the people help pay for part of the cost thru deductibles and copays and monthly fees for part B and drug part......why cant we let all americans of all ages participate in medicare....it would lower the cost for all...spread the risks from young to old.....ins. co. could participate like they do now in medicare suppliments....could cut the medicade roles....drug co would be happy cause everyone would be covered.....hosp and doctors would be happy because no indigent patients.....employers should be happy to get the burden off their backs......everyone would be covered and would pay for the ins (medicare) along with their tax.....therefore if someone shows up in e.r. or dr. office with no medicare care , that means he hasnt been paying tax on wages and the I R S should be called in to see if he is illegal or just guilt of tax fraud........It is workable and would end up being cheaper than what we have now....it is not socialized med....but the downfall is that the republican bigshots would never go for it, because they dont want everyone to have the same coverage.....a republican had rather make 10 dollars if other make 5...than to have everyone make 20

Anonymous said...

If the gov't would stop giving these handouts to people who are too lazy to work then the older generation that worked and put into the system would not have to do without food to pay their drug bill. Make these lazy people get out and work and pay for insurance for their kids instead of getting medicaid or peachcare, or welefare and foodstamps then the country would not be going overseas to get their products made by people who are willing to work for a little of nothing just to be able to feed their families. Bush is the best president that this country has had in a long time probably since before the president who signed the bill for giving gov't assistance to anyone who didn't want to work or didn't get enough of an education so that they could make more than minimum wage/

Anonymous said...

I give!!!
Socialism is inevitable in a country where people choose Government Ideas over Individual Thought.
This will not WORK because it does not demand nor congratulate WORK!
Rev.

GILLRILLA said...

Take it easy rev. You gona overload these people with the truth. They want the immigrants to do there dirty work, And its true they do work hard but now you can already see in atlanta you reap what you sew.Immigrant gangs spring up, immigrant mothers flooding the welfair office and the hospital,Thats why socialized meds. will not work. Every immigrant from every other country on the planet comes here to live off american taxes! Half of us pay tax the rest live off them. So we should say come on over guys bring your pregnant wife put her on welfair when she has a child and raise an idiot on us and by the way dont teach them to speak american we will change our language for you oh and by the way let us pay for it. Sounds like a hell of a plan to me.

Anonymous said...

"Bush is the best president that this country has had in a long time..." How can anyone with 1/2 a brain believe that????

Anonymous said...

they believe it because he says what they want to here...he is as big a racist and redneck as they are.....he is just a good ole boy.....out of his league....and it will take years before we repair the damage.....Rudy Guianli may be able to inject some good sense and goodwill back into the country.....he is just liberal enough to reach out to blacks, gays, immmigrants, and women.

Anonymous said...

You call him a racist- prove it you stupid F*ck. You are the same moldy scum that are sooooooo stupid you call him a NAZI. If people like you would educate yourselves just a wee little bit you would see straight through the name calling that is based on absolutely NO FACTS. If it is true then prove it and I'LL call the F*ckin media for you . I get soooo sick of STUPID PEOPLE THAT JUST REPEAT SENSELESS CRAP WITHOUT FACT!
Prove me wrong you stupid mother F-er.

Anonymous said...

The Coming Break-Up of America

By Frosty Wooldridge
July 9, 2004

Thomas W. Chittum, author of, "Civil War Two: The Coming Breakup of America," brings concrete historical evidence to the impending conflicts in America. By looking around, you, the average American, can see this
nightmare building.

If you're not living in California, Arizona, Colorado, Texas, Miami, Florida, Georgia, New York, Detroit, Michigan, Chicago, Illinois -- you might not see it ,but it's coming and it's coming fast.

Chittum states, "Street gangs will doubtless form the core of future black and Hispanic urban militias. Consider the following: .they are well financed by drug trade, they are ethnically-oriented, heavily armed, organized and disciplined and numerous beyond belief."

That statement is born out by the latest statistics whereby 29 percent of our state and federal prisons are filled with legal and illegal immigrants.

Former Attorney General Janet Reno put gang member totals on our streets at 500,000. Chittum states, "Their leadership is composed of courageous, industrious and intelligent men because promotion is based on leadership, business acumen and application of ruthless violence."

When you look at the massive drug trade infecting this country, it's evident. "These urban gangs are evolving into serious armies, armies hostile to the established government." It's why 800,000 Californians fled their state last year. In Miami, American citizens fled north.

Detroit is fast becoming exclusively Arabic. Fremont, Calif., is exclusively Middle Eastern in population. Los Angeles is no longer an American city.

As their numbers grow, police can't touch them because of "Special Order 40," which gives them immunity from arrest and deportation. Such governors as Baldacci in Maine and Arizona's Governor Janet Napolitano, a liberal Democrat, directly break immigration laws by passing ordinances, encouraging more illegal aliens and giving them sanctuary. The governor of Minnesota openly encourages massive illegal alien importation. He's pushed by meatpacking plant owners who openly hire illegal aliens. Austin, Minnesota suffers from more than 3,000 illegal aliens working in the meatpacking plants. Citizens are left without jobs while a few people make millions at the top.

Governor Bill Owens of Colorado does nothing to stop illegals in his state. Will Toor, mayor of Boulder, Colorado, openly encourages illegal aliens with sanctuary laws in his city. Eight women were raped last summer by illegals, but Toor continues supporting their presence in the city with jobs and housing. Immigration lawyers in Boulder brazenly present classes on how to avoid arrest and deportation for illegals.

It's astounding our own civic leaders aid, assist and abet this invasion against federal law.

How lethal are these gangs? Newsweek reported that there was a U.S. Justice Department "Street Gang Symposium" in Johnstown, Pa., in November of 1994: "Some gangs have access to highly sophisticated personal weapons such as grenades, machine guns, rocket launchers and military explosives."

"When civil authority breaks down in America," Chittum states, "our criminal gangs will fill the power vacuum, just exactly as has been the pattern in Third World countries."

Chittum quotes another dictator who succeeded: "A revolution is not a bed of roses," said Fidel Castro. "A revolution is a struggle to the death between the future and the past."

With 9.2 Mexicans now living on U.S. soil, a dozen cities sporting 51-percent foreign born immigrants, more than three million Middle Eastern immigrants enclaving against American values, it's a case of: Houston, we've got a problem. One of the aspects of the disintegration of Rome stemmed from its importation of Vandals that neither cared about Rome nor gave allegiance. In the end, they 'enclaved' more of their own until they became more powerful, by sheer numbers, than Romans.

The cult of 'diversity' and 'multiculturalism' being jammed down Americans' throats by both parties is an example of self-induced national suicide -- just like the Romans.

In a recent speech, former Colorado Governor Dick Lamm said, "My sixth point for America's downfall would be to include dual citizenship and promote divided loyalties. I would celebrate diversity over unity. I would stress differences rather than similarities.

Diverse people worldwide are mostly engaged in hating each other. That is when they are not killing ach other."

Chittum writes about economic collapse. He talks about how our own Congress ramrods two million immigrants down our throats annually while outsourcing, insourcing and offshoring jobs to other countries. How can we ever maintain a decent standard of living by adding 2.3 million people annually into the USA? Doesn't anyone 'get it' that the reason they are running out of Mexico and China stems from the fact that they can't feed, work, educate or clothe their own populations that explode out of control? Why create the same crisis here?

This year, American Flyer, the little red wagon that we all pulled in our childhoods -- offshored its production to China. But thousands of companies are moving production out of our country and leaving our people in unemployment lines. It's a lose-lose situation for U.S. citizens.

Chittum talks about Phases of Civil War II:

1.Tribalization, or the undermining of the concept of citizenship.

2. The creeping loss of democracy to private, governmental institutions and international bodies.

3. Gradually falling wages.

4. The slow decay of infrastructure in our cities and the abandonment by Americans and their replacement by minorities wedded to welfare and affirmative action.

5. Growing legal and illegal immigration to transform America into a typical Third World country.

6. Massive drive for gun control to cripple military potential from the working class.

7. Cooperation of the mass media to dumb down the population.

Near the end of the book Chittum makes projections that
you can see happening right now:

1.Shrinking hourly wage.

2. More immigrants than Americans.

3. Foreigners hold most federal debt.

4. Twenty million Third-World slums on our borders known as :colonias."

5. Manufacturing jobs moved out of the USA, making it impossible for us to make or sell anything to the world.

6. Republican and Democratic politicians refusing to deal with the immigration crisis. Worse, both parties aid and
abet it.

7. Growing power of advocates of Aztlan, the reconquest of California, Arizona, New Mexico and Texas by Mexico.

I must tell you fellow Americans this fact. Our country is in deep trouble and worsening fast. I spent two weeks on the border this spring from El Paso to San Diego. Immigrants successfully pour over our borders at 2,000 to 3,000 per day. That is upwards of one million annually. I saw them loading up in buses. I saw them squashed 30 to a van. I saw them crawling through the desert bush with my night vision scope. I interviewed Border Patrol officers who are hamstrung by Congress. The illegals they catch, they release on the border only to try again until they succeed. I saw the safe houses. I saw the lay-up areas. I saw the millions of pounds of trash left in the desert. I saw the invasion first-hand.

What can you do? Democracy is not a spectator sport. You need to start acting, writing, calling, pushing, shoving and screaming at your mayors, radio stations, newspapers and reps that you're tired of this invasion. Demand a 10-year moratorium for all immigration, now! Demand troops on the border. Demand English as our only language.

Demand no benefits for illegal aliens. Demand passage of S. 2671, the Clear Act. Demand HR 946 be passed to shut down legal immigration to fewer than 300,000 per year. Demand no amnesty for illegals. Demand that deportations begin. Demand the rule of law be followed and employers of illegals be arrested. Write me for action plans of what to do. Every letter will be answered.

Will Chittum's book prove prophetic? Will Rome's history become our history? It all depends on you.